One Singular Sensation

In Physics by Brian Koberlein8 Comments

There’s a new paper in Nature announcing the observation of magnetic monopoles.  Just to be clear, this is not the discovery of some new kind of particle.  Rather, these are simulated monopoles within a Bose-Einstein condensate.  These effective monopoles are useful because they can be used to study the ways in which magnetic monopoles interact.  While it is mainly a study of condensed matter physics, magnetic monopoles are extremely interesting to astrophysicists because they could solve one of the great mysteries of the universe.

Small threads suspended in oil align with the electric field of a charge.  Credit: NASA.

Small threads suspended in oil align with the electric field of a charge. Credit: NASA.

Many types of particles, such as protons and electrons, have electric charge.  Electrons and protons are electric monopoles, though we don’t usually refer to them that way.  This means they have a single charge, with protons being a positive monopole, and electrons being a negative one.  In our everyday experience, electrons and protons (and neutrons) tend to be bound together into atoms.  From at human-scale distances the positive and negative charges average out, so we don’t really notice them, but it is fairly easy to separate some of the positive and negative charges.  If you’ve ever gotten a static shock, it’s because you’ve separated a few too many positive and negative charges, and the shock is them coming together again.

Iron filings alined with a magnet's field.  Credit: Newton Henry Black, Harvey N. Davis .

Iron filings alined with a magnet’s field.
Credit: Newton Henry Black, Harvey N. Davis .

Magnets behave very differently.  A magnet has a north and south pole, similar to charges, but you can’t separate the poles.  If you break a magnet in half, then instead of getting a north magnet and a south magnet, you get two separate magnets, each with a north and south pole.  The reason for this is that the atoms or molecules that form a magnet each act as a small magnet, and are aligned to make a stronger one.  So it is impossible to separate the north and south poles in such a magnet.

The mystery comes from the fact that electricity and magnetism are connected as a fundamental force called electromagnetism.  One consequence of this is that moving charges can create magnetic forces and moving magnets can create electric forces, which lead to electromagnetic waves (light).  The equations that describe electromagnetism are symmetrical when it comes to treating electricity and magnetism.  But electric charge breaks this symmetry, because there are electric monopoles (charges), but there are no magnetic monopoles.

This might seem like much of a mystery, since it may just be the way the universe works.  Just because we’d like a theory to be symmetrical doesn’t make it so.  But if there were true magnetic monopoles, it would solve another mystery, known as charge quantization.  The charge of any particle can be given as an integer number of electron charges, either positive, negative, or zero.  This means that charge is quantized into charges of +2, -1, 0, etc.  You never see anything with a fractional charge.  (Some of you may ask “what about quarks?”, but these are always bound such that the total charge is an integer.)  Quantized charge is a basic aspect of physics, but we aren’t entirely sure why charge is quantized.

If magnetic monopoles exist, then this would solve the charge quantization mystery.  If you had a number of electric and magnetic charges, the electromagnetic field they produce would have a an angular momentum (rotation) that depends on value of the electric and magnetic charges.  In quantum mechanics angular momentum is quantized, which means the charges would also be quantized.  What’s particularly interesting is that even a single magnetic monopole would quantize all the electric charges in the universe.

There’s just one problem:  they’ve never been observed.  Several projects have tried to detect them, but none have been successful.  It’s possible that magnetic monopoles are too light to be observed by current detectors, but it’s also possible that they don’t exist.  The theoretical framework that proposes monopoles is compelling, but that’s not enough to support their existence.

But this new work in condensed matter may give clues on how we could detect magnetic monopoles (if they exist).

Paper:  Ray MW, Ruokokoski E, Kandel S, Möttönen M, Hall DS. Observation of Dirac monopoles in a synthetic magnetic field. Nature. 2014;505(7485):657-660.


  1. “Even a single magnetic monopole would quantize all the electric charges in the universe.”

    Can you please explain this point sir?

  2. (I don’t know anything about this, but I had a few thoughts)

    Could the reason that there are no magnetic monopoles be that ‘moving charges’ that pass through matter that lends itself to magnetism, give that same matter a distinct alignment as found in non-electric magnets? Therefore to be magnetic just necessitates the alignment of matter and to be a monopole depends on just being a charge, two distinct entities that cannot reconcile to ever be the same thing.

  3. Also, perhaps a magnetised 3D object could be magnetised to be so on just one part of its materially homogeneous form? It would be a magnetic monopole of sorts in that magnetism would exist and affect the space around it on a distinct side of the object but it may still have a north and south from the magnetised area of the object stretching to the area it affects. (Just theorising, I don’t know at all)

    1. Author

      Sure, the flow of charges in a magnetic field can create a magnetic field itself. In general it can be pretty complicated, but within a strong magnetic field it isn’t significant.

      1. Thanks Brian. I wonder if such a thing would happen between a binary black hole or neutron star gravitationally pulling on the surface matter of say a companion red dwarf towards itself?

Leave a Reply