Ripples on the Cosmic Pond

In Cosmology by Brian Koberlein1 Comment

Time for more on the cosmic microwave background (CMB).  This time for something really cool.  You’ll remember that the CMB isn’t perfectly uniform but instead has little variations in temperature.  Some regions are slightly hotter, and some are slightly cooler.  This is similar to having ripples on the surface of a pond, where some parts of the surface are slightly higher than the average pond-level, and some slightly lower.

The pond analogy is a pretty good one, because you could imagine studying the ripples to figure out what caused them.  If you could show, for example, that ripples moved out in circles from a central point, you would know that a stone was dropped in the water there.  If you measure the size of the largest ripples, and know their speed, you could calculate when the stone was dropped.  You could look at other ripples and figure out they were caused by the wind, and maybe a large ripple caused by a passing boat.

We can do a similar thing with the CMB.  The way we do it is by looking at the power of the CMB at different scales, called a power spectrum.   In mathematical terms we expand the ripples into a sum of multipole moments. Basically just take the total average temperature of the whole sky, then split the sky into two regions and take an average of each section, then split and average again, and so on.  Keep doing that, and you get an “average” temperature at each scale, which you can see in the figure below.

Now some scales are more powerful than others, and that tells us about what factors are causing the ripples.  Using our pond analogy you might have more little ripples on the pond than big ones, which would tell you that more stones cause the ripples than boats.  For the CMB, the effects are things like the value of the Hubble constant, how much dark energy and dark matter you have, etc.

In the figure below, I’ve not only plotted the observed power spectrum as data points, I’ve also plotted a theoretical curve that agrees with the data.  This theoretical curve is the shape you’d expect for a universe that is 74% dark energy, 22% dark matter, 4% regular matter (stars, planets and us), and is about 13.7 billion years old.  We have other ways of determining each of these values, and they agree with these values.


The amazing thing is that all these values fit in this single curve.  If the values were different the peaks would shift left or right, or be higher or lower.  While the image of the CMB is wonderful, with its swirls of color, this graph is even more wonderful.  It tells us that our understanding of the universe is on track.

Not bad for looking at ripples in our cosmic pond.


  1. Here what I’ve wrote in my article presented at Linked In some time ago.
    Vortices could be found all the way around us. Assuming different kinds of vortices possess common generics, at least, in some extent, we can get an insight in understanding the hardly accessible and/or observable vortices, for instance, cosmic black holes, by observing the easily accessible ones, for example, liquid vortices.
    The liquid vortex I’ve observed was arranged to confine the vortex developments proceeding in the water thin surface layer thus making it to act as a two-dimensional rather than a tri-dimensional one and to consider the developments as being reasonably generic ones likely related to the black hole developments.
    Liquid vortex was observed to emanate double spiral waves. The reason causing the double spiral appearance was found to be associated with the spinning funnel bottom asymmetry, which most of the time was shaped as a distorted digit 8. Seemingly, an asymmetry in the spinning vortex geometry, specifically in black hole mass distribution, even a slight one, must inevitably cause generation of propagating away spiral gravitational waves carrying momentum and energy. Meaning that spinning black holes dynamically distort/ripple the spacetime, spreading energetic gravitational (spiral) waves. Which, in cosmic timescale, will make quite a fraction of the accrued mass/energy. Also meaning that, the gravitational waves from different black holes, interfering with each other should make the Universe filled with energy possessing gravitational ripples. Like the ocean surface.

Leave a Reply